The Interior Department's
Fall
by John G. Lankford
PFNS, Alamogordo, NM When Congress returns
from recess in September, the
Interior Department will squirm.
In an autumn when many see the federal
government as a bloated monster in
meltdown, when more are uneasy due to the War
on Terrorism and the
problematic economy, and westerners are
enraged over record forest fires,
that department has managed to don a flashing
neon sign reading "Kick Me."
For a decade and more, Congress has both
appeased and exploited citizen
anger by calling top officials of government
bureaus on the carpet in
televised hearings, scolding them fiercely for
public consumption, and later
quietly raising their budgets. In 1994, the
Departments of Education, Energy
and Commerce were under assault. Later,
grandstanders attacked the Treasury
Department's Internal Revenue Service. All
survived and indeed prospered,
but they did so in quieter times.
The Interior Department was traditionally a
tranquil fief, taking care of
the nation's parks and other federal real
estate, and handling relations
with Indian tribes. But it was quietly
infiltrated by fervent environmental
absolutists and, as a close and hard-fought
off-year election approaches,
their antics have made it a laser-sighted
target.
From September until November's election,
members of Congress not
grandstanding for themselves will be doing so
for their parties, seeking
ways to break the virtually even power split
in government. Because people
vote more readily against than for, they will
be jostling to be seen as
champions of the righteously indignant. The
Interior Department is emerging
as the season's most conspicuous single object
of anger, and there is no
compelling national need for it to survive.
Almost all it does, individual
States can do.
There is a mammoth state/federal Comprehensive
Everglades Restoration
Project floundering in Florida, one that has
cost and will cost billions.
There is a little patch of slightly high
ground on the edge of the
Everglades National Park, officially
designated the "8.5 Square Mile
Area"
(8.5 SMA). Gardeners, small-plot farmers, and
shopkeepers live there. Some
claim, and others deny, the 8.5 SMA obstructs
all or part of the Everglades
Project.
For nearly two decades, Congress has held the
8.5 SMA does not and provided
for its protection from Everglades waters
raised by the Project with a
little levee-and-canal system. The Army Corps
of Engineers was to build the
levee and canal system and the Interior
Department's National Park Service
was to pay the federal share of its cost from
money Congress appropriated.
But the little flood protection system was not
built, the Project was
augmented and modified, and the Park Service
always refused to release the
money for the Area's flood protection. The
Service wants to buy it,
voluntarily if possible, and by eminent domain
if necessary. To that agency
the inhabitants are virtual, though not
literal "inholders," owners of
private property surrounded by National Park
or Forest.
In order to get on with the vast Everglades
Project, the Corps of Engineers
acquiesced and signaled intent to proceed with
its own "Alternative 6D."
That is a compromise plan to acquire part of
the 8.5 SMA as a Park "buffer"
and protect the rest. The plan assumes
groundwater will forbear to seek its
own level in the protected part, or pumps to
overcome seepage would be
adequate and affordable.
But 8.5 SMA residents sued and won a federal
district court judgment holding
Congress had never intended to authorize
eminent domain buyouts in the 8.5
SMA, and Alternative 6D could not proceed. In
exasperation or churlishness,
the Engineers last week declared the entire
Everglades Project at a
standstill.
The plight of the residents, whose land is
often and, they charge,
deliberately flooded by Project-elevated
waters, drew the attention of The
Paragon Foundation. Having caused revision or
reversal of the Interior
Department's Park Service and Bureau of Land
Management programs in Klamath
Falls, Oregon; Jarbidge River in Elko County,
Nevada; and Darby, Ohio;
Paragon made the 8.5 SMA its next campaign.
The Foundation and allies
declared a "Sawgrass Rebellion" and
scheduled transnational caravans
scheduled to converge for a rally near the 8.5
SMA October 17-19.
The Interior Department's 2003 funding bill
(HR 5093), passed by the House
and ready for floor debate and vote in the
Senate, is the subject of a
tug-of-war between federal land-taking
advocates and private property
protectors in Congress. A clause that would
annul the federal court's
decision and mandate the Engineers' building
the 6D Alternative "without
delay" and "notwithstanding any
other provision of law" was inserted in
committee in the House, but struck before
passage and referral to the
Senate. Florida Senator Bob Graham (D) is
considering an effort to restore
the clause.
To aggravate the imbroglio, that bill is one
means eyed by western members
of Congress seeking to expedite firefighting,
fire-damage relief, and future
fire prevention funding. There is pressure to
pass it quickly, one reason it
was not referred to committee in the Senate.
If Graham succeeds, the House may not pass the
bill. If it does, the
President may not sign it. If he does, he will
vindicate years of
bureaucratic defiance of Congress. But Bush
has just announced a veto of a
$5 billion supplemental appropriations bill he
considers profligate. By way
of his Homeland Security initiative, he is
trying to restore subordination
of some of the executive branch's
bureaucracies to the President. Interior's
Bureau of Indian Affairs is also scrambling to
explain the disappearance of
as much as $10 billion in Indian trust funds.
Now the Park Service has galvanized property
rights defenders again with
studies looking to the eminent domain taking
of almost 336 square miles of
Santa Barbara County, California. The Park
Service goal is to add a
provisionally named Gaviota National Park to
Channel Islands National Park
and Point Reyes National Seashore, which are
already in their grasp.
Among those furious is the formidable American
Land Rights Association and
Darby, Ohio struggle veteran Julie Smithson.
In a comment letter filed as
part of the Park proposal study, Smithson
compassed the dissolution of the
Park Service and the Interior Department.
Thanks to bureaucratic blundering,
overzealousness, and political ineptitude
at Interior, she may get her wish.
-00-
PFNS is a public service of The Paragon
Foundation, Alamogordo, NM
1-877-847-3443